Psychometrics for Recruitment: Enhancing your hiring process

Written by Sally-Ann King | 7th July 2025

In today’s competitive talent marketplace, making the right recruitment decision first time is crucial. Hiring the wrong person is a costly and frustrating mistake to make, especially with businesses facing tightening costs and battling for talent in tough employment markets.

At Reality HR, we always recommend employers use a range of tools during recruitment and selection processes, including structured interviews, aptitude or ability tests, and group assessments.

Carrying out a Psychometric assessment is another valuable tool employers can use to learn more about how a candidate might work and behave in the workplace.

Get in touch for more information

What are psychometric assessments in the recruitment context?

Psychometric assessment for recruitment is a way to measure the potential behaviours of individuals in a work setting. They are not an indication of strengths and weaknesses, or skills and capabilities, but rather indicate a person’s natural styles and preferred ways of working.

Candidates complete an online multiple-choice questionnaire to generate a personal profile that indicates:

• How they prefer to communicate
• Their natural leadership and management style
• How they tend to operate as part of a team
• The type of work environment and culture they enjoy working in that will enable them to flourish

It is important to remember that although people may have certain preferences or natural styles, most are able to adapt their approach depending on the situation. The profiles provide a good basis for discussion so you can really understand your candidate’s likely behaviours better.

In addition to the personality/behavioural questionnaires, you could also use psychometric assessments for

• verbal reasoning – the ability to understand written information they evaluate candidates’ abilities to process information and make decisions, particularly in roles that require strong analytical and communication skills.
• numerical reasoning – how they think using numbers providing a way to measure a candidate’s ability to understand and interpret numerical data, including graphs, percentages and different types of calculations. These are particularly useful with finance and engineering roles.
• abstract or spatial reasoning – the ability to understand patterns, logical rules or work with shapes
• situational judgement assessments- set a scene and ask what they would do in that situation

How psychometric assessments transform the recruitment process

Psychometric assessments, can be useful in recruitment, but should only be part of a robust selection process, to understand whether candidates would be suitable for a job role and how they might fit in with your team  They can also be a good indication of a candidate’s verbal and numerical skill which is useful to evaluate when recruiting for key roles that require accuracy and attention to detail… However, psychometrics must be used with caution. You should ensure you use a tool that is designed to support a robust process and never base any hiring decisions on personality profiles alone.

The profile generated by the assessment can suggest:
• The type of culture and work environment the candidate prefers to work in
• The methods they might use when handling conflict
• Their preferred style when working in a team or group
• How they might react when faced with challenges

They can be particularly useful for more senior roles, indicating whether a new manager may be more transactional or transformational in style, whether their leadership approach might be more motivating, democratic, visionary or perhaps pragmatic, and whether they may have the level of empathy and emotional intelligence that enables them to relate to and inspire their team.

Why psychometrics matter in an AI-driven application world

As AI tools become more accessible, many candidates are using them to help write CVs, tailor cover letters, or prepare for interviews. While this can help applicants present themselves more effectively, it also makes it harder for employers to truly understand the person behind the application.

Psychometric assessments offer a solution to this challenge by providing a deeper, unbiased insight into a candidate’s natural behaviours and preferences – something that can’t easily be generated or disguised with AI. These assessments go beyond polished documents and rehearsed answers to uncover the genuine characteristics that influence how someone will work, lead, and collaborate in your organisation.

By incorporating psychometric assessments into your process, you reduce the risk of being swayed by a CV enhanced with generative AI tools and gain a more rounded understanding of who your candidates really are and their capabilities

The Reality HR approach to psychometrics in recruitment

At Reality HR, we take a holistic approach to psychometric assessments in recruitment:

1. We assess job requirements first – Identifying which psychological attributes are most relevant to success in the specific role
2. We integrate psychometrics as one element of a comprehensive assessment strategy
3. We interpret results contextually – Understanding that there are no “right” or “wrong” profiles, only different fits for different roles
4. We focus on dialogue – Using results to facilitate meaningful conversations about work preferences and environments
5. We emphasise ethical application – Ensuring assessments never disadvantage protected groups or create unfair barriers

Employers should use a reputable test, administered by a licensed practitioner and then use the results to identify areas that you can then probe further during interviews. Never use the profiles alone to judge a candidate or to make a hiring decision. The bottom line is that they work best when they are used in conjunction with other evaluation methods, to help build the bigger picture and not push you to hire or not to hire someone based purely on the test result.

Benefits of psychometric assessments in recruitment

As we’ve previously explored in our overview of psychometric assessment pros and cons, these assessments offer several advantages when incorporated into your selection process. When specifically applied to recruitment, the benefits include:

1. Highlight development opportunities

Every candidate dreads the question, “what are you not so good at?” The most common response might be, “I am too much of a perfectionist!” A psychometric test can highlight areas of concern and give you an opportunity to explore these areas before hiring. As you already have an idea of their skills or behaviour gaps, you can put a development strategy and plan in place to support them.

2. Show good cultural fits

Some psychometric assessments will provide you with information on the type of environment the candidate prefers to work within, so this will allow you to explore how they would fit in your workplace.

Personality profiles can give you an insight into a candidate’s preference for behaviours too. For example, it might show that they tend to be quiet, or they tend to be emotional and spontaneous, and with this in mind you can explore at interview how this might fit with your current team and culture.

Hiring someone who looks great on paper but struggles to settle in, or even worse, disrupts the team can be a costly and time-consuming mistake that as an employer you’ll want to avoid.

3. Show suitability for a role

Psychometrics can help you build appropriate competency-based questions to use in interviews to find out whether a candidate is suited to the role, e.g. looking for a logical thinker, a quick decision maker, a confident networker, but remember that personality profiles measure preference and not ability, so cannot be relied upon alone as a predictor of future performance.

Challenges of psychometric assessment in recruitment

1. Test accuracy

Most reputable assessments will be well designed to drive out accurate results, for example asking the same question in multiple ways to ascertain the consistency of someone’s answers. If a candidate thinks too much about their answers or tries to second guess what the “right” answer would be, it is unlikely to give an accurate indication of who they truly are. In these tests, there are no right and wrongs for the candidate or the employer; recruitment is always about finding the right person for the team, and the right team for the person.

2. The assessments may put certain individuals at a disadvantage

If someone has a different cultural background, a language barrier or neurodivergence, they might not test as well as others and not necessarily because they are not a good fit for the role. Recruiters must always be flexible in their approach and adjust their selection processes to enable candidates to fairly access the process and be able to demonstrate the value they can bring to the team in whatever way they can.

3. They need to be delivered by trained specialists

Psychometric assessment requires licensed practitioners to carry out the assessments and interpret them.

When to consider psychometrics in your recruitment process

Psychometric assessments are particularly valuable when:

• Hiring for leadership or management positions where interpersonal skills and emotional intelligence are critical
• Building cohesive teams that need complementary personalities
• Making high-stakes hiring decisions with significant implications
• Developing internal talent pipelines and succession planning
• Reducing unconscious bias in selection processes
• Improving retention rates through better initial fit
• Where verbal and numerical accuracy is absolutely key in the role

Best practices when using psychometrics for recruitment

Based on our extensive experience with psychometric assessments, we recommend:

• Never use psychometrics as the sole decision factor – they should complement other assessment methods
• Ensure assessments are administered consistently across all candidates for a position
• Provide clear explanations to candidates about the purpose and process
• Offer feedback to candidates on their results when possible
• Review the relevance of assessments regularly to ensure they align with evolving job requirements
• Work with certified practitioners who understand both the science and application of psychometrics

Getting started with psychometrics for recruitment

Reality HR has trained and experienced consultants who regularly recommend and implement Quest and other tools with our clients, for use during recruitment, personal development or coaching, and team building.

We can help you:

1. Determine whether psychometric assessment would add value to your specific recruitment challenges
2. Select the most appropriate assessment tools for your needs
3. Integrate psychometric insights into your broader recruitment strategy
4. Train your hiring managers on interpreting and applying the results effectively
5. Develop follow-up interview questions based on psychometric findings

With hiring decisions becoming more complex, psychometric assessment can provide valuable insight to support a fair and balanced recruitment process. Used alongside other assessment tools, it can help you better understand how a candidate might fit into your team and work environment.

About the author: Sally-Ann King, Recruiter

Sally-Ann is a very knowledgeable recruiter with over 30 years of experience recruiting across many disciplines and sectors.  She has extensive experience of the Graduate and Apprentice market and has recruited for many roles including C-Suite and Senior Teams.  She is familiar with many different types of interviewing techniques, enabling her to select only the best candidates.

She knows the importance of candidate care and despite the outcome of screening and selection, will always engage with the candidates to let them know.  Building candidate relationships is vital during the journey.  She recognises that recruitment is a two-way process, ensuring not only the candidate is right for the business but that the business is right for the candidate, and they are treated respectfully throughout.

If you’d like to explore whether psychometrics could support your recruitment challenges, our team is happy to talk it through. Call us on 01256 328 428.